By now, the true innovation of our era may be in the choreography of virtue: the panel, the audit, the dashboard, the values campaign, all staged to prove responsibility without ever surrendering control. It is easy to mistake more rituals for more care. But anyone who has sat through a post-mortem town hall or glossy transparency memo knows how often these spectacles exhaust dissent instead of enabling it. What passes for transparency is frequently a technology for managing consequence, not sharing it: failure is scripted into apologies and metrics while the machinery of extraction not only survives, but earns fresh legitimacy.